Feedback request: map graphics 1 or 2?
Once again I have a small feedback request for my sheepherding game... This time I'd love a comment whether map style 1 or 2 is the most appropriate. Okay, we're not talking the Mona Lisa in either one, but which would you prefer? Please note that the first isn't a finished version, but maybe you'll get an idea of the style anyway.
The first:
http://www.cynicalstuff.com/files/map1.jpg
The second:
http://www.cynicalstuff.com/files/map2.jpg
Update: I made a few changes according to suggestions, and the second one turned into this:
http://www.cynicalstuff.com/files/map3.jpg
And this is a screenshot of the main gameplay, if you're wondering what the context is:
http://www.cynicalstuff.com/files/screenshot2.jpg
There are good and bad points to both map styles (in my opinion), and I can't decide whether to go with one or the other. I'm sure some of you'd feel that neither is good enough, but alas! - it seems my budget doesn't permit better art at the moment.
A simple vote for 1 or 2 would be excellent. If you have some suggestion like "the first would be decent if you changed this or that" it'd be even better!
Reply With Quote